Comments on: Sami Jamil Jadallah – The Hell with Israel, Open the Sea Port of Gaza!

By: Aaron Aarons

Aaron Aarons — Thu, 12 Mar 2009 09:19:35 +0000

Whatever one thinks of Hamas' strategy, it is unacceptable imperialist chauvinism to support an arms embargo against Hamas while Israel continues to import, manufacture, use and export far more powerful weapons than any Palestinian faction could hope to obtain. Moreover, Hamas and other anti-imperialist factions need weapons to deal with U.S./Israeli-owned Quislings like Abbas and Dahlen. And inviting the U.S. to have any more presence in that region than it already has is a crime against present victims of U.S. imperialism (Iraq, Somalia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, etc.) as well as future victims.

BTW, if Hezbollah hadn't had Iran weapons, could they, despite their skill and dedication, have resisted Israel as well as they did?

By: ioana

ioana — Sat, 07 Mar 2009 22:22:52 +0000

the comment on 1 and 5 is very funny – this article is in fact among the most "balanced" and pragmatic on this site (it is, of course, pro-Palestinian – being on PTT, it seems normal one should care about Palestine -, but it is rather critical towards Hamas's strategy and open to an American/ European control of the port). So maybe the fact that it is "balanced" is more upsetting to an Israeli eye; given that the Israeli hypocritical propaganda is "we love the Palestinians, but hate Hamas", it perhaps finds itself uncovered faced to a position that states: Palestine comes first.
Eventually, the comment reads "You are a propagandist and a racist for not presenting balanced picture of the conflict", but the purpose of the article is not to present the conflict – the conflict has made itself evident to the whole world through the slaughter in Gaza – but to propose a solution. But obviously the Israeli politics has never sought a solution to the conflict; on the contrary, it has always tried to: 1. present to the world the biased image of the conflict and at the same time make sure that it is accepted by everybody just like anything related to Israel, and 2. get rid of the Palestinian term of the problem instead of trying to solve the conflict.

By: Sami Jamil Jadallah

Sami Jamil Jadallah — Sat, 07 Mar 2009 13:53:07 +0000

Thank you Emily for your compliments. I was hoping you have the smart and intelligence to write your own words rather than using the same language and text as that of Sdfd. I take your advice under consideration and in my next posting I will give Israel full exposure as the “only democracy” in the Middle East, and will give its very efficient army my compliment. Yes, indeed, Israel is a light unto other nations, except this light comes in the form of phosphorous and cluster bombs. I do think that G-d made a big mistake; He/She must have been too desperate.

By: Emily

Emily — Sat, 07 Mar 2009 07:37:19 +0000

I think this is probably the worst article I have ever read. So full of propaganda and lies it is ridiculous. People like you should be banned from journalism. Not once do you point out that Hamas continues to fire motars at Israels for the last seven years. Not once do you mention how Hamas is targetting civilians. Not once do you mention that there were underground tunnels wide enough to drive trucks from Egypt to Gaza. You are a propagandist and a racist for not presenting balanced picture of the conflict.

By: Sami Jamil Jadallah

Sami Jamil Jadallah — Sat, 07 Mar 2009 00:26:49 +0000

Well, I have to say “my cousin” has lots of Chutzpah and having lived and worked with my cousins, I learned it too. May I suggest to “my cousin” who accused me of being unfair, unbalanced and an idiot, I suggest this. Let Hamas have all of the weapons at the disposal of the Israeli Army including all of the F-16s. F-15s. Drones, Apache and Cobra Helicopters, Armored Personal Carriers, Tanks, 155 mm Howitzers and all of the gun boats and I say, let Israel have 1,000,000 Qassam rockets and have all of the tunnels with Egypt. I would say this will be a fair trade and will be balance since there is complete substitutions and exchange of roles and equipment of the two groups. And yes, let Gaza becomes Sderot and Ashkelon and let Sderot and Ashkelon become Gaza. Not for five years but for 3 weeks or 22 days to be exact. That will be a fair trade and a fair balance of terror. I am sure “my cousin”, smart, fair and balance he is, will not object to that. This reminds of Eddy Murphy movie "trading places". Very funny movie indeed. Shalom/Peace/Salam.

By: Mary Rizzo

Mary Rizzo — Fri, 06 Mar 2009 23:31:13 +0000

ahahah! Sami, that was a very good apology. A friend of mine told me that he was watching Israeli tv on satellite and they spent about 10 minutes filming a wrecked kitchen countertop! He said that if it were not so surreal, it would seem like a parody. The people were actually moaning, going "Who is going to pay for all of this!?"

The lack of a sense of proportion is probably the most atrocious thing that jumps to the eye.

Ok, they want balance? let's work it out this way: every victim will get one minute of dedication, with a photo, some information about what that person did in life and where he or she was born… then the other side gets their minute and back and forth. To be balanced, so that true proportion is respected (balance is not being 50 50, but it is giving the accurate amount of emphasis to equivalent situations no matter who the victim is in this case) it would mean that the israeli section would be over in a few minutes. Then, an eternal list of victims. After the deaths, we go to see the wounded, then the material damage…

then… as you say, we go to the West Bank and compare it to the Israelis.

It would make for accurate information. At this point, though, Israel would need to go for the only tool they know – lies and propaganda. The truth is not on their side!

By: Sami Jamil Jadallah

Sami Jamil Jadallah — Fri, 06 Mar 2009 23:02:47 +0000

Yes, of course, I have to be fair to the Israelis. Poor Israelis, they suffered great deal from Qassam Ballistic and Nuclear missiles. Over 5,000 of these useless and reckless missiles fired by Hamas toward Southern Israeli towns creating big damage and causing irreparable harm. Two Israelis are know to die from these powerful missiles, few homes partially destroyed, otherwise the Israeli residence were having difficult time enjoying their dinner with music and wine. Across the border in besieged Gaza, more than 1.5 millions are left without lights, food, gas, cooking oil with hospitals putting at risk hundreds of patients because of lack of power. People are unable to bake bread or cook food, or have heat or gasoline for emergency purposes. Dozens of people died because of lack of medications and access to emergency services. Dozens of people were killed by Israeli tanks and Israeli gun boats, including a family killed at it was enjoying quite afternoon at sea side. Meanwhile across the borders on the West Bank, some 80,000 Palestinians in Hebron have to live life under daily curfew so that some 400 Jewish Settlers can enjoy themselves, dance on the streets, and throw garbage at Palestinian homes and residence and evict them from their own homes. More than 2.5 millions have to face cruel humiliations and a daily life going through some 500 security checkpoints where a 10 minutes distance is turned into a day long affairs, where pregnant women died while waiting to get permission to go to hospitals. More than 300,000 olive trees where uprooted to make room for Jewish Only Road, and to make room for settlements built on stolen Palestinian properties, including mine. Tens of thousands of Palestinians lost their residency in Jerusalem simply because they are Palestinians, part of the deliberate ethnic cleansing of Jerusalem of its Arab citizens. Thousands of thousands of homes were destroyed because Israel claims the people did not have permits to build and where a Palestinian have to wait for 15 years to get a permit to build an addition to his house for his newly married son, while Jewish settlers are given permission to build tens of thousands of homes as a matter of public policies and build them on land they do not own. Yes, of course poor Israelis they are suffering a great deal living under Palestinian Occupation and living under the threat of Hamas rockets. Perhaps the Israelis like to exchange position with the Palestinians not for one week, or 42 years but for one day. Yes, I am unfair to Israel and its occupation, and yes, I did not mention the Wall and its impact on the daily lives of people and farmers. I also did not mention the fact that entire Arab towns do not have daily access to drinking water so that Jewish settlers can have green and healthy lawns and can enjoy their swimming pools. Yes, poor Israelis they really have it rough, and again, I apologize for not being fair to Israel and its occupation. It must be part of my genetic trait as an Arab.

By: Mary Rizzo

Mary Rizzo — Fri, 06 Mar 2009 22:06:07 +0000

this was posted by Sdfd, and since it violates at least one of the rules. PTT encourages free speech, but it does not present a platform for Zionist propaganda. If those who don't like what is written want to call it propaganda, they can complain on their own sites. However, we sent the comment to Sami. First, the original comment, then Sami's reply:

Its people like you who perpetuate the conflict. Instead of portraying an accurate picture of reality you make one side so fanatical peace will never have a chance.

Idiot!

Sami replied:
I am sure all Zionist and Jewish media and apologists like Daniel Pipes, Steve Emerson, Alan Dershowitz and Elie Wiesel always published balanced articles showing what Israel is doing to the Palestinians from targeted killings to destruction of homes and farms, to checkpoints to arrests and detentions without trial to ethnic cleansing and of course all Zionist and Jewish media also showed the extent of destruction of Gaza and openly debate the war crimes committed by Israeli politicians and soldiers. So please do not tell me about being fair and balanced. Why should we represent the Israeli point of view when you have the Jerusalem Post, the Chicago Tribune, the Weekly Standard, the Washington Post, the New York Post, the New York Times, Fox News, CNN, ABC, NBC and many other media and we have our little Palestine Think Tank.Give our side equal times in your media,and I am sure I will then give Israel equal times in my posting. Thank you