Israel Foreign Affairs Ministry: Lies are Truth
By Mary Rizzo • May 10th, 2008 at 14:57 • Category: Analysis, Hasbara Deconstruction Site, Israel, Palestine, Zionism
The people in the press staff of the Israeli Foreign Affairs Ministry are talented science fiction writers. Almost nothing that they write has any bearing on reality, and it seems that they use Orwell’s 1984 as a guidebook for news dispatches. All that they need to do is look at the facts on the ground (terminology that was invented by the hasbara commission, more than likely, because it is something different than reality. It has a bit of the sense of imposition of a negative reality that cannot however be challenged by ‘ordinary’ people), and turn them on their heads. War is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength. That’s exactly how the Israeli PR staff represents reality with their warped mirror.
I do suggest, for those who, like myself, find some pleasure in reading nonsense, to subscribe to their newsletter or to read it on their site. It is just about as absurd a thing one can find to read. The trouble with it is: it’s taken seriously by the Big Mass Media and a lot of the dispatch services never verify any of the information that is released. If you wonder just why everyone is so wrong about Israel and Palestine, look no further.
On 7 May, this was their press release. I will deconstruct it. Their original in Israeli Blue.
Behind the Headlines: Hamas holding civilian population in Gaza hostage.
How’s that for a shock headline? It is as if the people of Gaza are in a concentration camp and kept hostage. Well, they are, of course, but it’s not Hamas who has locked them in and thrown away the keys, but this does not matter. Israel KNOWS that people are going to notice sooner or later that Gaza has become the place on earth where the greatest number of people are confined and held hostage, but passing the stick to Hamas is going to resolve any nasty questions about who is keeping them prisoner.
By seizing the fuel, food, and medical supplies that Israel is transferring to the Gaza Strip, and using the supplies itself, the Hamas terror organization is basically holding the civilian population of Gaza hostage.
Ah, so all of these wonderful things have been delivered by generous Israel to Gaza? No one has seen any of it, so it must be the bad guys of Hamas who have diverted all of it and probably are storing everything in warehouses, or selling it on the black market. The crossings have all been closed, but no one should become aware of the fact, unless they wonder how a million and a half people can get by without replacement of the material that is consumed. Naturally, it’s not a good idea to indicate to people that a blockade has been made in order to break the resistance of these people, which at least are classified as civilians by the people who bomb them indiscriminately when it suits them. But for Israel, all that material has arrived, in fact, Israel itself is transferring it to the Gaza Strip! But since things have a material presence, they don’t just disappear, the culprit for these enormous quantities of goods simply NOT BEING THERE has got to be the bad guys. Hamas can’t let anyone see all the truckloads of material, including fuel, that Israel is donating. Seizing it for political purposes, so they can justify the uprising. Well, of course, none of that is true. Since the siege started last fall, little to nothing has entered into the Gaza Strip, and very little has gotten out. The population is indeed being held hostage, but Israel is doing a three card shuffle – blame it on Hamas (repeat as well that they are a ‘terror organization’) so that it’s easier to insert in a copy and paste journalist report.
Israel has supplied nothing, nor have they let anyone else do so. Yet, to deny material sustenance would be a crime against humanity, because the occupier is obligated to provide for the people who are being occupied. However, Israel will state that they no longer occupy the Gaza Strip. “We left! The settlers are gone,” they say. Well, one does not have to have colonial presence to exact control over a territory. All that needs to be done is to control its borders, and Israel does just that: stick them in the prison and let them fight it out between themselves is the policy that Israel has decided to enact in order to bring Gazans to their knees or, failing that, make them beg for Fatah to take control of the elections Hamas won, therefore, giving Israel the electoral results they wanted but were denied. Israel controls the air space, territorial waters, offshore maritime access, and the border between Israel and Gaza, with most of the crossings being closed even for those needing medical assistance. Egypt controls the southern border. This means that they are committing crimes against humanity by denying Gazans aid, food, fuel and freedom of movement. But, they won’t admit it. In fact, that’s what the lie about Hamas taking the materials is there to cover.
It is apparent to those who invent this lie, and it is tragic that many believe it! Hamas does not have any control over the crossings of incoming goods. Nothing has been turned back or stashed away for the simple reason that nothing has been delivered! The humanitarian crisis in Gaza is far from artificial. It is real and evident to anyone who has access to view it. Clearly, the crisis was created by Israel, but passing the buck of the ‘international pressure’ is the only remedy that Israel can come up with. They have no intention to break the siege. It is in their interests to continue it to the bitter end. Unfortunately, neither Gazans nor Hamas can do anything to change this. We are going to see a long, hot summer ahead, and Israel is doing damage control.
Recent reports indicate that not only is Hamas depriving the civilization population, it is allocating the supplies for its own use.
Then, we get a flaming headline:
Hamas steal fuel from the civilian population
http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G1-172296528.html
So, who is stealing fuel from the civilian population? Ask the Israeli Defence Ministry all about their instructions.
Of course, these international reports are very worrying if one takes them by the soundbites provided by Israel. Take the London Independent report:
Last night Hamas proposed a six-month cease-fire with Israel, saying the Gaza Palestinian group would stop firing rockets into the Jewish state if Israel lifts its blockade of the coastal strip at the same time, Egypt’s state run Mena news agency reported.
The report came after a day of closed-door meetings between Egypt’s powerful intelligence chief Omar Suleiman, who has been mediating between Hamas and Israel, and Hamas’ strongman, Mahmoud Zahar.
Under the international boycott imposed after Hamas seized Gaza by force last June, Israel’s declared policy has been to allow in enough fuel, food and medical supplies to keep people alive, but not enough for them to live well.
So, even the best article that Israel propaganda experts could fine from an independent source point out something that doesn’t make Israel look too wonderful:
Namely, Hamas has offered a cease-fire of the Qassam Rockets (which at any rate cause limited damage). It is willing to come to a solution to have the blockade lifted. Evidently, while this is what Israel claims is behind the blockade, when action is taken to do so, they refuse to accept it and blame Hamas of being terrorists and depriving their own people of things they need to live. Ah, but remember, Israel admits it will KEEP PEOPLE ALIVE, at some level of survival, but they are going to have to suffer. Sounds like Auschwitz to me.
On 24 April, the Presidency of the EU
Who is this reporter? I never heard of him, but he’s very famous in Israel. Here is something to give us an idea of who our source is:
Nissim Keinan, nationally famous for his Voice of Israel broadcasts from the Sderot and Gaza regions, told Arutz-7 the IDF Gaza offensive accomplished a “drop in the ocean” of what needs to be done.
Nissim Keinan is the voice heard several times a day on national radio, reporting from the south on Kassam rockets in Sderot, terrorist activity from within Gaza, and nearly everything else that goes on in that area of the country.
Speaking with Arutz-7´s Hebrew newsmagazine on Monday, Keinan said, “Yes, it was a successful operation, but it appears that the terrorist activity will simply revert right away to the way it was before. We’re talking about looking for a needle in a haystack - because Beit Hanoun, where the offensive took place, is just a small town of 30,000 people; but what about Beit Lahiya and all its terrorists? And what about Jebalya, and the entire area of the Shati refugee camp, and the Khan Yunis area, and Dir el-Balach - I mean, the entire place is swarming with terrorists. Just because you took care of one place and confiscated weapons and ammunitions, it still doesn’t mean that you´ve achieved the goals.”
“In any event,” Keinan continued without stopping, “it´s strange to hear the army talk of such great successes, when really it was just a routine operation. They moved the Kassam launchers southward, true - but you can fire Kassams from the south too, you know, and they also fire them from the north. Yes, the accuracy of the firing has been impaired, but they were never accurate; they just shoot and it hits wherever it hits.”
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/115008
The Summer Rain Offensive was a Drop in the Ocean of what needs to be done? So, Keinan thinks that 197 civilians and 48 children killed by the IDF is a good and positive thing? Sounds again, a hell of a lot like Auschwitz to me. So, I leave you to speculate on his final words here:
Mary Rizzo is an art restorer, translator and writer living in Italy.
Email this author | All posts by Mary Rizzo

Great deconstruction and analysis, Mary. Thank you so much to alerting me to Palestine Think Tank. I will come back often and refer my friends. I just saw the latest issue of Campus Life that are customized for the local colleges, and on the last page there was a photo essay on Israel’s 60th birthday. Not a single mention of the Nakba even though in one picture with a young Israeli woman hurt in a bus bombing (and whose husband left her and her 8-month old baby shortly afterward) was a young (Palestinian?) girl with a headscarf that they didn’t even bother to identify. It’s as if only Israeli suffering has any merit and everyone else is virtually invisible. And these are not the outwardly pro-Zionist publications; these are the supposedly neutral ones that still more often than not promote the official Zionist narrative.
You’ve certainly got an uphill battle ahead of you yet I am somewhat optimistic in that you have the truth on your side and a seemingly inexhaustible reserve of determination and perserverence.
My sincere gratitude and admiration to you all.
LT
Hi Lance! Great to see you here and thanks for your thumbs-up (in a Sisbert kind of way…). The determination is there, and when they close down one site, we open up three more…. It’s like Gilad wrote recently: if they stop you from shouting, you speak, if they cut your tounge out, you nod, if they behead you, you become a martyr and thousands more are affected by your words and the crimes they did to stop you only make them criminals, and you more effective.
Ah, the Campus Life stuff… that is interesting! I love these documents…. If you would like to write a deconstruction of them for the Think Tank, we would be really honoured to host that here!
I’ve been working for a while on The Torch (from CUFI) and The Israel Project…. they are world class liars! But still, look at who is feeding them the lies: direct from the source!
Hi Mary,
I’ll see what I can come up with. The actual name of the publication is Campus Circle ( http://www.campuscircle.com/ ) and the issue was April 30th - May 6th. I’m trying to find a link to the photo essay online. I also plan to write them to ask about similar coverage of the Nakba.
I just saw a Prof. Lieber on C-SPAN talking about Israel and when a caller mentioned Israeli apartheid, the professor grew indignant and declared any comparison to South African apartheid “obscene.” I do not think a day goes by where some news feature or public affairs discussion is covered with an unmistakeably Zionsit slant.
Going back to the original hard copy of the publications, I found something that was surprising to me. One is that they actually did identify the girl with the headscarf by name (Manar) though they gave out no details in the caption (was she a friend, servant, neighbor, family-member, etc?) but that the Campus Circle publication was very selective of the photos they used. The source is Gillian Laub from a photo study called “Testimony” with essays by Ariella Azoulay and Raef Zreik and actually covers victims of the conflict in Israel and palestine from a number of vantage points as opposed to the ones highlighting an Israeli perspective only (2 of the 5 shots used were of IDF) . The author actually provides a wider narrative to the consequences of the conflict than the publiction did. While there is no online link from the magazine for the photo feature, there are for the author and her work and are linked at the end here. I wonder if the publication’s omission of Arab victims was merely an oversight, a conscious choice, or done out of concern that humanizing Arab victims might bring some sort of backlash?
http://www.aperture.org/store/books-detail-promo.aspx?ID=551
http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/1127/p13s01-bogn.html